Comparing Baby Registries: Find the best baby regsitry

by Julie Siewert September 04, 2020

Comparing Baby Registries: Find the best baby regsitry

There are so many choices for baby registries! Between your favorite stores and the dedicated baby registry websites, how are new parents to choose which registry is the best?! Comparing baby registries side-by-side is the easiest way to find out which baby registry is right for you.

Many of the baby registries have different features; some offer a "free" baby box or welcome box, others offer a "completion discount", free shipping, or even a "concierge service". So many choices!

Hopefully this chart will help you compare the features of many of the top baby registries.


  Amazon Babylist Blueprint Gugu Guru MyRegistry Target

FREE Welcome Gift

yes, with Prime Membership and a $10 purchase from your registry yes, with $10 purchase from Babylist store, plus $6.99 shipping no no no yes, in-store

Universal Registry

(add gifts from any store online)

✔️ ✔️ ✔️ ✔️ ✔️ ✔️
In-store registry no no no no no ✔️
Concierge (FREE help registering) no no no ✔️ no no
Group gifting option ✔️ no ✔️ no no ✔️
Completion discount 10% (15% if you have Prime membership) 15% from Babylist store no no no 15%
Extended returns 365 days no no no no 1 year
Mobile app ✔️ ✔️ no no ✔️ ✔️
Free shipping Free shipping on orders over $25, or Free shipping with Prime no no no no Free shipping with Red Card on orders over $35
Ask for non-physical gifts (ie: dog walking, babysitting, meals) no ✔️ no no no no
Ask for cash gifts Amazon gift cards ✔️ ✔️ no ✔️ no


Looking for more in-depth information on all the baby registries, including step-by step instructions on how to add gifts from ANY website? Check out our Exploring Baby Registries Series, including Amazon Baby Registry, Babylist, Blueprint,, and Target Baby Registry.


Photo of 12 packs of diaper samples with text of 5 star review "I am all about a useful gift. If you know anything about babies, every diaper fits every baby differently. So, instead of getting a bunch of boxes of different diapers for the expecting mother to try (and inevitably waste) I found this! GENIUS!"

The Natural Choice for New Babies Diaper Sampler Package is a great gift for new parents to try a variety of eco-friendly diapers. Add one to your baby registry! (hint: find your registry on the list to see step-by-step instructions to add an item from ANY website to your existing baby registry)


Looking for what to include on your Baby Registry? Here's our handy checklist of ALL the baby items you want on your registry


Photo of gift wrapped presents with text "Comparing Baby Registries: Find the best baby registry" 


Happy Registering!

Also in Behind the Store

Diaper Brand Spotlight Series: Dyper
Diaper Brand Spotlight Series: Dyper

by Julie Siewert December 11, 2023

Read More
Amazon Prime Big Deal Days Sale
Amazon Prime Big Deal Days Sale

by Julie Siewert October 09, 2023

Read More
What's the Difference Between all the Pampers Diapers?
What's the Difference Between all the Pampers Diapers?

by Julie Siewert September 27, 2023

Read More